 Myles_Kornblatt Posted on 11.17.2008
| Automakers and the U.S. Government: more investment, less aid
I am usually a big fan of laissez-faire in big business. In most cases I don’t believe in government intervention, but I am a car guy first and a businessman second. I don’t like the idea of just handing out money. That’s why my suggestion is to have the government also take a percentage of the company. So that when the U.S. auto industry recovers (and I truly believe it will,) the government will get some real money back for coming to the rescue. That’s something that doesn’t happen on a low-interest loan against company assets. As pointed out earlier this is not communism and more like mercantilism. This is good for the state. Because if GM goes under, then there will be multiple hundreds of thousands of people out of work who will now need to draw money from the government. When General Motors is talking about bankruptcy it may not be talking about Chapter 11 (reorganization); it may be talking about Chapter 7 (liquidation). The government is going to have to pay either way, but at least with government investment, we get to keep our car companies. No one else will currently take on the large burden that is GM. No company is big enough to swallow GM as a whole. If General Motors goes bankrupt, a few foreign brands will be sold off as a whole, like Opel to Europe and Buick to China, but most domestic brands will become shells. Names like Chevy or Cadillac may find homes as rebadged versions of foreign cars, but most General Motors dealers and factories in North America will close. The ripple for this was covered earlier. There will absolutely be a domino effect from any domestic automakers bankruptcy because the American public follows publicity. In the 70s and early 80s publicity about how American cars were inferior to Japanese ones dealt a blow to the industry. Americans began to think that American cars were junk and didn’t look at domestics again. While in many cases this was, it was not the case the whole time. There was a real problem with cars like the Datsun B210 rusting while still in the showroom, but people bought them over ALL domestics because of perception. Also the government can’t take a controlling interest in auto companies, because it will be a disaster that will kill off any cars with soul. One of the biggest problems in the government-controlled British Leyland is that the company had to get approval for it new car lines from the British Government. This meant everything went a typical governmental pace (laborious) and rarely were purse strings loosened so that an exciting car could get through. There does need to be fresh blood in the executive ranks for a full organization, but that is a topic all on its own. Let’s hope the auto industries make it that far to where we can have that discussion. react... |